Roofing Myths Central PA Homeowners Should Stop Believing

Central Pennsylvania has its quirks. Lancaster has Amish buggies cruising past Target and York still treats scrapple like a competitive sport. What we do not need is roofing myths floating around like clingy pollen on a windy day.

We want to squash some of those rumors.

So lets get started and straighten a few things out.

Myth 1: Your shingles are old so it is time to replace the whole roof

This one gets tossed around endlessly and basically anywhere a roofer owns a ladder. Someone walks up, looks at your roof, and suddenly your 18 year old shingles are being treated like ancient relics.

Reality is not nearly that dramatic. Around the Mid Atlantic, a well installed shingle roof will often last 25 to 30 years and sometimes longer. We have been on thousands of roofs and plenty of them were still going strong at the 30 year mark.

If a contractor insists your 18 to 22 year old roof is finished, get another opinion. Your roof might still have a perfectly healthy decade left in it.

Myth 2: You have hail damage and your insurance will pay for a new roof

This pitch pops up all over Pennsylvania. A roofer knocks and tells you there is hail damage that will qualify you for a free roof. Sounds like winning the lottery until you realize severe hail damage is extremely rare in Central PA.

The type of hail that actually shortens the life of shingles does not happen around here very often. We have even seen contractors create fake hail marks to file claims. Now, we aren't saying every roofer is out there staging crime scenes on people’s roofs, but it does happen and it drives up insurance costs for everyone.

If someone claims you have hail damage, slow down. Get a second opinion before you get roped into something shady.

Myth 3: Your roof is too old to repair and you should replace it instead

Once a roof hits 15 years old, some contractors treat repairs like a waste of time. They say it is not worth investing in and you should jump straight to a replacement.

This isn't quite true. A 15 to 20 year old roof can still have a lot of life left. We regularly repair roofs that other companies have written off. If your roof is closer to 25 years old and showing serious wear, then sure, a roof replacement becomes the obvious choice. But repairs are often dismissed way too early in our neck of the woods.

Before you sign for a full replacement, make sure repairs are truly off the table

.

Myth 4: You can install shingles anytime in winter without issues

Technically, you can. But practically? It really depends. Winter across the Susquehanna Valley makes asphalt shingles stiff and brittle. Nail depth matters. Handling matters. Experience matters. If cold weather installation is done carelessly, you end up with cracked shingles, nails pulling through and a shorter roof life.

A winter install done the right way will last just as long as a summer install. A winter install done the wrong way will not. That is the difference between a crew that knows how to handle cold weather work and a crew that just wants to squeeze in another job before spring.

What homeowners across Central PA actually need to know

Whether you live in Lancaster, York, Lebanon, Harrisburg, or any of the small towns in between, roofing should not feel like a guessing game. You deserve real information, not scare tactics. You deserve advice based on the lifespan of roofs in our region, not the lifespan of a contractor’s sales quota.



Straight talk, honest assessments and work done the right way are how homes stay protected in Central PA. And if you ever need someone to help decode roofing nonsense or double check what another company told you, reach out to us! We'd be more than glad to help.